Welcome to Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden, a delightful dining destination nestled in the vibrant heart of Key West. Our menu promises an unforgettable culinary experience, blending classic tavern favorites with local flair. Guests will discover dishes like the Smithwick’s Ale Battered Grouper Fish & Chips, known for its perfectly crisp batter and flaky fish, along with the irresistible Reuben egg rolls that have garnered rave reviews.
The atmosphere is equally inviting, boasting a beautiful garden patio overlooking bustling Duval Street. Our friendly staff is dedicated to enhancing your visit, offering knowledgeable recommendations and impeccable service. Whether you’re enjoying a refreshing Key Lime Colata or sharing a hearty meal with friends, every moment at Old Town Tavern & Beer Garden is designed for comfort and satisfaction. Experience the essence of Key West dining—where every plate tells a story!
Food - Share (Online)
Black Bean Hummus
US$10.00Cauliflower Bites
US$12.00Chicken Wings
US$16.00Fried Mozzarella
US$10.00Meatballs
US$14.00Pork Belly
US$12.00Reuben Egg Rolls
US$14.00Shoestring Fries
US$8.00Tuna Poke
US$17.00 Food - Start
Gazpacho
US$8.00Scotch Eggs
US$14.00 Food - Flatbreads (Online)
Cheese Flatbread
US$10.00Pig N' Pickle Flatbread
US$17.00Shrimp Scampi Flatbread
US$19.00Summer Garden Flatbread
US$16.00 Food - Greens
Burrata Salad
US$14.00Grilled Greek Salad
US$12.00Mixed Greens
US$10.00Superfood Salad
US$12.00Tavern Wedge
US$10.00 Food - Add Ons
Blackened Cauliflower Florets
US$5.00Blackened Grouper
US$12.00Grilled Shrimp
US$9.00Marinated Chicken Breast
US$7.00 Food - Pub Favorites
Bangers & Mash
US$21.00Fish & Chips
US$24.00Glazed Chicken Stir-Fry
US$29.00Marinated Rib Eye
US$36.00Shepherds Pie
US$20.00Shrimp Linguine
US$29.00 Food - Hands
Blackened Cauliflower Wrap
US$17.00Chipotle Chicken Sandwich
US$17.00Vegetable Banh Mi
US$17.00Chicken Banh Mi
US$17.00Pork Banh Mi
US$17.00Grouper Sandwich
US$20.00Tavern Steak Sandwich
US$19.00Cheesy Pete Burger
US$18.00Old Town Burger
US$18.00Lost Cowboy Burger
US$20.00Hangover Burger
US$22.00Burger Special
US$19.00 Food - Kids
Chicken Tenders
US$8.00Fruit & Vege Bowl
US$8.00Kids Pasta
US$6.00 Food - Sauces, Sides
Bread - Croustini
US$1.00Bread - Extra Croustini
US$0.50Bread - Extra Toasted
US$0.50Bread - Toasted
US$1.00Extra Vege
US$1.00Side 1000 Island
US$0.50Side Balsamic Reduction
US$0.50Side BBQ Sauce
US$0.50Side Blue Cheese Dressing
US$0.50Side Brandy Peppercorn Cream Sauce
US$5.00Side Chipotle Aioli
US$0.50Side Citrus Viniagrette
US$0.50Side Garlic Aioli
US$0.50Side Ginger Miso Mayo
US$0.50Side House Hot Sauce
US$0.50Side Jerk Sauce
US$0.50Side Marinara
US$0.50Side Mayo
US$0.50Side Mustard
US$0.50Side Mustard Sauce
US$0.50Side Olive Oil
US$0.50Side Orange Beet Vin.
US$0.50Side Parmesan
US$0.50Side Ranch
US$0.50Side Sage Onion Gravy
US$4.00Side Soy & Honey Sauce
US$0.50Side Sweet Chili Sauce
US$0.50Side Tartar
US$0.50Side Tomato Relish
US$1.00